A/B Testing: What It Is & How to Optimize Email Campaigns

Definition

A/B testing is a method of comparing two versions of an email to determine which performs better. By sending variant A to one segment and variant B to another, marketers can measure differences in open rates, click-through rates, or conversions. The winning version is then sent to the remaining audience or used as the standard for future campaigns.

Common Use Cases

Test subject lines to improve email open rates

Compare different call-to-action buttons to increase click-through rates

Evaluate send times to find when your audience is most responsive

Test email layouts and designs to boost engagement

Compare personalization approaches (first name vs. company name)

Measure the impact of different offers or incentives on conversions

Why A/B Testing Matters

A/B testing removes guesswork from email marketing decisions. Instead of assuming what your audience prefers, you let data guide your strategy. Even small improvements in open rates or click rates compound over time, leading to significantly better campaign performance and ROI. Regular testing helps you understand your audience better and adapt to changing preferences.

How A/B Testing Works

A/B testing starts by selecting a single variable to test, such as the subject line, sender name, or call-to-action button. Your email list is split into two random groups of equal size. Each group receives a different version of the email at the same time. After a set period, you compare the results using your chosen metric (open rate, click rate, or conversions) to identify the winner. Statistical significance ensures the results are reliable, not due to chance.

Best Practices

Test only one variable at a time for clear, actionable results

Use a large enough sample size to ensure statistical significance

Run tests for an adequate duration before declaring a winner

Document your tests and results to build institutional knowledge

Start with high-impact elements like subject lines and CTAs

Apply winning insights to future campaigns consistently

Verify your email list before testing to ensure accurate results

Avoid testing during unusual periods like holidays when behavior may differ

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between A/B testing and multivariate testing?

A/B testing compares two versions with one variable changed, while multivariate testing examines multiple variables simultaneously. A/B testing is simpler and requires smaller sample sizes, making it ideal for most email campaigns. Multivariate testing is better for complex optimization when you have large lists.

How long should I run an A/B test?

Most email A/B tests should run for 2-4 hours before selecting a winner, though this depends on your list size and open patterns. Wait until you have enough responses to reach statistical significance, typically at least 100-200 opens per variant. Some email platforms automate this process.

What should I test first in my email campaigns?

Start with subject lines since they have the biggest impact on open rates. Once optimized, move to call-to-action buttons, send times, and email layout. Focus on elements that directly affect your primary goal, whether that is opens, clicks, or conversions.

A/B Testing

Every email term you need to master email marketing and email deliverability, explained clearly and simply.